The AI Backlash Isn’t Against AI. It’s Against Us.

The graffiti is everywhere now. Walk through a New York subway and you'll see AI startup ads defaced with "Get real friends" and "AI doesn't care if you live or die." Scroll through social media and watch the term "slop" become shorthand for everything hollow about AI-generated content. The backlash is here, it's loud, and frankly—parts of it are completely justified.

When 43% of Americans now believe AI will harm them more than help them, when campaigns using generative AI get mocked as lazy and soulless, when artists watch their voices get cloned without consent—these aren't just growing pains. They're real problems that deserve real scrutiny.

But here's what the conversation is missing: the backlash isn't really about the technology. It's about how we're using it.

Writer AI's CEO May Habib just delivered one of the most brutal assessments of corporate AI failures I've seen: 42% of Fortune 500 executives say AI is actively "tearing their companies apart." Not because the tools don't work. Because leaders are treating AI like just another software rollout and delegating it to IT departments, when it actually requires a fundamental rethinking of how work gets done.

This is where marketing teams have a massive opportunity—and a massive responsibility.

The companies creating "AI slop"? They're not using AI strategically. They're using it as a shortcut, a replacement for human creativity rather than an amplification of it. They're deploying it without clear frameworks, without understanding its limitations, without asking "Should we?" before "Can we?"

But when you use AI with intention—when you build proper workflows, maintain creative control, and understand what these tools are actually good for—that's when the magic happens. That's when you go from seven months to 30 days on a creative campaign. That's when you liberate your team from bureaucratic scar tissue to focus on judgment, strategy, and creativity.

I understand the impulse to reject AI entirely. But as a marketing professional, you don't have that luxury. Your competitors are figuring this out. Your customers are already using these tools. The only question is: will you learn to wield AI strategically, or will you let it wield you?

The answer to AI backlash isn't to avoid AI. It's to use it better—with clearer frameworks, stronger guardrails, and a commitment to amplifying human creativity rather than replacing it.

That's what this newsletter is about. Not AI hype. Not uncritical adoption. But practical, strategic, empowering use of the most powerful marketing tools we've ever had access to.

Let's dig in.

🔥 This Week's Hot Takes: AI Marketing Edition

AI Backlash Reaches New Heights as Public Patience Wears Thin (Newsweek) – Public skepticism toward AI has escalated into open hostility, with defaced advertisements and campaigns mocked online. The Friend startup's $1 million NYC subway campaign was vandalized with messages like "get real friends" and "surveillance capitalism." Meanwhile, 43% of Americans now believe AI will harm them more than help them, up from one in five in 2022. The backlash targets both quality issues and the perception that AI primarily benefits Silicon Valley's wealthiest while solving few actual problems.

AI Is 'Tearing Companies Apart' (VentureBeat) – Writer AI CEO May Habib revealed shocking survey results at the TED AI conference: nearly half of Fortune 500 C-suite executives believe AI is actively damaging their organizations. The culprit isn't the technology but leadership's fundamental misunderstanding. Companies are treating AI transformation like previous software rollouts and delegating to IT, when it actually requires wholesale reorganization of how work gets done. Habib argues that billions are being wasted on AI initiatives going nowhere because leaders won't personally drive transformation.

AI Marketing Adoption Has a Sequencing Problem, Not a Technology Problem (CMSWire) – While 60% of marketers use AI daily and nearly one in five dedicate over 40% of budget to AI tools, fewer than 1% report reaching AI maturity. The barrier isn't the technology—it's choice overload and poor sequencing. Companies jump into flashy use cases before fixing data quality, workflows, or governance, leading to the 95% pilot failure rate. Success requires disciplined sequencing: fixing data foundations first, aligning tools to existing workflows, establishing governance, then scaling methodically.

Marketing in the AI Era Has a Marketing Problem (Crunchbase News) – Optimizely President Shafqat Islam argues that marketing's credibility crisis stems from overpromising what AI can deliver. Instead of proving worth through complex attribution models and vanity metrics, marketers need to focus on whether they're driving actual sales and pipeline. Marketing amplifies strengths and exposes weaknesses but cannot create substance where none exists. The path forward requires honest acknowledgment of failures, focus on business outcomes over metrics, and treating marketing as continuous learning rather than perfect execution.

Stop Optimizing, Start Reinventing: Three Marketing Imperatives for 2026 (Forrester) – Forrester's analysis from MAICON 2025 reveals that while productivity gains are table stakes, the real opportunity lies in 10x thinking rather than 10% optimization.

Consumer Trust in AI Remains Low Despite Growing Adoption (eMarketer) – By 2027, Gen Alpha will surpass baby boomers in generative AI usage, highlighting rapid normalization among younger demographics. However, about half of US adults say increased AI use will hurt creative thinking and relationships. Lack of human connection and privacy concerns top non-users' reasons for avoiding AI. The research reveals a fundamental tension: AI is becoming integral to marketing processes, but consumer trust lags significantly behind adoption rates.

B2B Marketing AI Adoption Driven by Partnership Between CMOs and CIOs (Forrester) – Leading AI adopters in B2B marketing share key characteristics: close CMO-CIO partnerships (twice as likely compared to laggards), focus on data-driven operations with 94% of marketing data relied upon for business decisions, and investment in foundational AI readiness including policies and training.

McKinsey: CMOs and CFOs Must Unite to Close Marketing Tech ROI Gap (Fortune) – McKinsey's survey of 200+ senior marketing and technology leaders reveals a stark problem: none of the 50+ marketing leaders interviewed could clearly articulate their martech ROI.

Generative AI Changes Customer Experience—But Human Judgment Still Essential (MarketingProfs) – While AI-generated responses can reference past purchases and tailor recommendations, success depends on human oversight.

PPC Trends 2026: Platforms Making More Decisions Without Asking First (Search Engine Journal) – Performance Max and Demand Gen have shifted from experimental to default, with AI generating ad copy and selecting audiences based on invisible signals.

Major Brands Reject AI in Advertising, Betting on Authenticity (Business Insider / Yahoo Finance) – Polaroid, Heineken, and Aerie are leading an anti-AI advertising movement, tapping into consumer weariness.

Anthropic Launches 'Skills' to Customize Claude for Specialized Tasks (Anthropic) – Claude can now use Skills—folders containing instructions, scripts, and resources—to perform specialized tasks like creating Excel files or following brand guidelines.

🧪 The Alchemist's Lab: Tools I've Been Testing

Persana AI Function: AI-powered sales prospecting and GTM engine that tracks 75+ buying intent signals across 100+ data sources. Marketing Application: Persana combines enrichment with full go-to-market automation, enabling teams to find prospects, track buyer signals (job changes, funding rounds, website visits, keyword intent), and automate personalized outreach Pricing: Subscription-based (specific pricing available via demo)

🤖 AI Whispers (That You'll Want to Shout About)

The implications for marketers are becoming crystal clear across multiple dimensions:

The Trust Economy Is Now Everything – With 43% of Americans believing AI will harm more than help, and AI-generated ads shown to trigger 12% more distrust than human-created content, transparency isn't optional anymore. Brands that win will be those that use AI strategically while being radically transparent about when and how they're using it.

Content as Data Layer Is the Next Evolution – The shift from content as static assets to content as structured, machine-readable data layers represents the biggest strategic pivot for content teams. Agents need entity graphs, canonical definitions, and provenance trails. Humans need narratives and proof. Marketing teams must design for both simultaneously.

🏆 My Take: What This Means for Your Marketing

Here's the ONE key insight from this week: The backlash isn't killing AI marketing—it's forcing a long-overdue reckoning about implementation.

The companies creating "AI slop" aren't failing because AI doesn't work. They're failing because they're using it as a shortcut instead of an amplifier. They're deploying it without frameworks, without understanding limitations, without asking "Should we?" before "Can we?"

But when you use AI with intention—when you fix your data first, align tools to workflows, establish clear governance, and maintain creative control—that's when you go from seven months to 30 days on a campaign. That's when you liberate your team from bureaucratic scar tissue to focus on judgment, strategy, and creativity.

Your immediate action item: Before you launch another AI pilot, answer these three questions honestly:

1. Is our data clean enough for AI to make good decisions?

2. Does this fit into how our team actually works today?

3. Have we established who owns governance and how we'll measure success?

If you can't answer yes to all three, pause the pilot and fix the foundations first. I promise you'll move faster in the long run.

Before You Go: Hit reply and tell me - what's your biggest AI marketing challenge right now? I read every response and it helps shape future newsletters!

That's a wrap on this week's AI marketing alchemy! Keep experimenting, keep transforming, and remember - true magic happens when we blend AI efficiency with human creativity.

Crafted with passion (and a dash of AI alchemy) by Lisa Peyton | AI Marketer, Professor, and Innovator

Let's connect in the digital realm: https://linktr.ee/lisapeyton

🎁 Thanksgiving Day Deal: 50% Off All AI Marketing Courses Through October 31

The season of gratitude always reminds me how lucky I am to learn alongside such an inspiring community of colleagues, students, and dear friends.

Every Thanksgiving, I like to give back to the amazing marketing and communications pros who make this community what it is.

This year's TDay Deal is live: 50% off all my AI marketing courses through October 31.

It's my way of saying thank you for showing up with curiosity, creativity, and courage during a time when marketing is transforming faster than ever.

If you've been waiting for the right moment to dive in, this is it. Let's make this season one of growth, reflection, and creative renewal.

🎁 Learn more and enroll here: https://maven.com/lisa-peyton/ai-for-strategic-content-marketing?promoCode=TDAY